Shweta Thakur posted an Question
September 18, 2020 • 03:50 am 30 points
  • IIT JAM
  • Chemistry (CY)

I am asking why they have not put a minus sign with work done formula for expansion.... l be rehe sink a giet the appropriate conventions of sig

uring the opctaton, an amount of heat , exactly equal to w, will be returned to the sink at theat has been giet tc SStem. smg the appropriate conventions of sign, 4 Wil be negauv . Isothermal Expansion. The cylinder containing one Re ok the ideal gas, occupying a volume , is placed in contact 2t tae souree (e, heat reservoir at temperature 7,). The ga atsorhs heat , from the source and expands isothermally and versibiy till its volume has increased to The path of the pocess is representod by the isothermal curve AB Snce the 8as is ideal, the wvork done, w, by one mole of the ideal gas will be given by ACV 5 will be poSitive so that BV 1sOTHERMAL (T2 - RT, In IV. Adiabatie Compression. The cylinder is now removed from the sink and placed agan o oNASOTHERMAL sulating nmatertat. ne gas is then compressed adiabatically and reversibly along DA till the initat stiate 4 insula regained. The temperature of the gas rises from 7 to T, The work done is positive by the conventons cV L (T) s (6) - RT In (1) sign and Wlt be given by w =C, (7-7) Further, for an ideal gas, the work done is equal to the heat absorbed, 9, So that VOLUME As a result of these four operations, the system has returned to its original state so that a reversible eyc FIGURE 2.1. Carnot cycle. has been compietcd. he net work OP) done by the system will be given by -4 RT, In Here, has been taken as egative and 92 a5 pOsz{ive by the latest SI conventions of sign. -RT, I-c, (7,-7)+RT, ln+C, -7) INSULATION 8) = RT, ln+ RT, In 1 Since and lie on one adiabatic curve and V and V lie on another, it follows that V /3 (10) 2 and sOURCE AT T2 INSULATION MATERIAL SINK AT T1 INSULATION MATERIAL Comparing cquations (9) and (10), we get FIGURE 2.2. Different operations of the Carnot cycle. (- IL Adiabatic Expansion. The cylinder is now removed from the source and placed in perfectly insulating material so that the gas now expands adiabatically and reversibly. Work is done in the expansion but since no heat enters or leaves the system, the temperature must fall. The reversible adiabatic expansion is continued till the temperature has fallen to 7, which is the temperature of the sink. Suppose the corresponding volume becomes3 The path is shown by the adiabatic curve BC in Fig. 2.1. The work done w, Will be given by (11) Putting this value in cquation (8), we get V2 RT, In+ RT, In RT, In - Rr, ln V -W C, (7-7,) =-C, T -T7) 3) = R (T-71) In here is the heat capacity of the ideal gas. Here, again w, is negative by the usual conventions of sign. Dividing equation (12) by equation (2), we get IL Isothermal Compression. The cylinder is now removed from the insulating material andplaced in ntact with the sink (i.e., the heat reversoirat the lower temperature 77). The gas is compressed isothermally i reversibly till the volume decreases from V to V. The process is represented by the path CD in F1g. 2.1. work done is taken as positive by the usual conventions of sigr and hence will be given by which gives the efficiency of the Carnot cycle or engine, .4) " = RT, In THERMODYNAMICS II Pradeep's PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY VOL. 11

2 Answer(s) Answer Now
  • 0 Likes
  • 3 Comments
  • 0 Shares
  • comment-profile-img>
    Priyanshu kumar Best Answer

    The numerical value of this work is negative and the magnitude of the work is given by the area under the curve...so here work is equal to magnitude of w1 that is |w1| which is work done by the system here

    eduncle-logo-app

    So it is shown negative but its magnitude is taken so taken as positive

    eduncle-logo-app

    magnitude kyun le re hain

    eduncle-logo-app

    aisa no hona Chahiye tha

    eduncle-logo-app

    Shweta carnot cycle alag alag book me alag tarike se samjhaya gya hai

    eduncle-logo-app

    But in carnot cycle as we take area under the curve so take their magnitude

    eduncle-logo-app

    ok sir

    eduncle-logo-app

    bs question dekhte hain kaise hote hain

    eduncle-logo-app

    sir

whatsapp-btn

Do You Want Better RANK in Your Exam?

Start Your Preparations with Eduncle’s FREE Study Material

  • Updated Syllabus, Paper Pattern & Full Exam Details
  • Sample Theory of Most Important Topic
  • Model Test Paper with Detailed Solutions
  • Last 5 Years Question Papers & Answers